Homestead Rescue has captured the hearts of many viewers, showcasing the Raney family—Marty, Misty, and Matt—helping struggling homesteaders turn their dreams into reality. Their expertise and dedication are widely appreciated, but over the years, some fans have raised valid concerns, particularly about their approach to safety.
Lack of Protective Gear: Leading by Example?
One of the primary concerns repeatedly voiced by viewers is the apparent lack of personal protective equipment (PPE) while performing high-risk tasks. A Reddit user recently pointed out:
“Let’s cut down this giant tree! That I have never done before! No hard hat, no eye protection, no gloves, no respiratory protection from dust, sawdust, mold, etc…. But a thin shirt always opened to his naval. And let kids watch and learn this!”
This raises an important issue—should professionals on television set a better example when it comes to safety? Viewers argue that as experienced homesteaders, the Raneys should be demonstrating best practices, including the consistent use of safety goggles, gloves, hard hats, and other protective equipment.
Another point of contention among fans is the occasional use of questionable methods to complete tasks. A viewer noted:
“There was a bit in a recent episode, I don’t remember which one, where Misty told a homesteader, ‘I don’t know if this is the right way to do this, but it’s the way I learned!’ and I felt like that said SO MUCH.”
While experience is valuable, a show like Homestead Rescue carries the responsibility of educating its audience with safe and effective techniques. Using improvised methods without proper verification may not be the best approach when millions of viewers, including aspiring homesteaders, are watching and potentially emulating these practices.
The Dangers of Improvised Equipment
One of the most alarming incidents mentioned by fans involved Marty using a small bottle jack to steer the direction of a falling tree—a move that, according to professional lumberjacks, could have had disastrous consequences. A Reddit user recalled:
“Don’t forget that time when he used a small bottle jack to try to steer the direction a tree would fall and almost killed everybody for the sake of the story and shot. Yes, pros do that, but they use real gear and not something out of the trunk of a car lol.”
While television thrives on dramatization, safety should never be compromised for the sake of creating suspense. Fans have pointed out that professionals in similar fields use proper gear and techniques to mitigate risks, and the Raneys should follow suit.
Are the Right People Getting Help?
Another concern raised by viewers is whether the Raneys are truly helping those in need. A fan pointed out an issue with Season 9, Episode 3 (No Place Like Dome):
“Why did the Raneys help these people? They are basically glamping. Each day they had perfect clothes straight out of the package, really didn’t help out, had no skills. I prefer to see them help people truly in need.”
This comment highlights a shift in the perception of the show. Some viewers feel that Homestead Rescue should focus on assisting those who are genuinely struggling, rather than individuals who may not be fully committed to the homesteading lifestyle. The authenticity of the homesteaders’ hardships plays a crucial role in maintaining the show’s credibility.
Concerns About the Show’s Direction: Donations and Assistance
A new fan of the show shared observations after binging several episodes, pointing out issues with how some homesteaders take advantage of the Raneys’ help. One particular episode stood out:
“We’ve been living off-grid for seven years. Discovered Homestead Rescue a month ago and have been binging episodes. Have picked up a few great ideas to implement.
But a couple of things bother me: First… the episode with a family of six living in one house in Mississippi. When the Raneys showed up, the property was littered with garbage. The homesteaders blamed it on the goats. Then the scene where Misty is bulldozing an area that looked like a garbage dump. Very disappointed that the Raneys used their valuable time to do what the owners should have done in the first place. They looked like a really lazy family IMO. And yes, I have some compassion that they’ve had a house burn down, another taken by flood. My gut tells me they’re jinxed with bad luck.”
The fan also highlighted a noticeable shift in the show’s format:
“And why the change in the show where a big reveal at the end of the episode shows the Raneys have found companies donating buildings, sheds, drilling, etc.? Homesteading/off-grid shouldn’t be about GoFundMe campaigns or getting other people to do your work for you. Bottom line, if you can’t afford to be off-grid, go back to the city.”
This raises an interesting debate about the essence of homesteading. Many fans argue that homesteading is about self-sufficiency, hard work, and personal responsibility. Some feel that the increasing reliance on external donations and corporate assistance undermines the true spirit of off-grid living. Others, however, appreciate that these contributions provide struggling families with a much-needed boost.
The Argument Against Safety Measures
Not everyone agrees that a change is necessary. Some viewers believe that safety precautions may not always align with the rugged homesteading lifestyle. As one user stated:
“I’m an electrician and I think this is just the way crafty people are…. gritty homesteaders would probably not pay too much attention to safety. I hate wearing my safety shit at work and I wouldn’t wear it if it wasn’t required.”
This perspective highlights a broader debate: should Homestead Rescue reflect the reality of experienced homesteaders who work with minimal safety measures, or should it take the opportunity to set a higher standard?
Conclusion: Time for the Raneys to Prioritize Safety and Authenticity?
While Homestead Rescue continues to be an engaging and inspiring show, it may be time for the Raneys to consider making safety a bigger priority. Wearing protective gear, using verified techniques, and avoiding dangerous improvisations could enhance both the credibility and educational value of the show.
Additionally, some fans believe that the show should refocus on helping truly struggling homesteaders rather than those who appear to be looking for an easy way out. Ensuring that assistance goes to those genuinely committed to off-grid living could restore authenticity to the show’s mission.
Viewers appreciate the Raneys’ dedication, but leading by example with proper safety measures and maintaining the spirit of self-reliance would only strengthen their impact. After all, safety and hard work aren’t just about protecting and sustaining themselves—it’s about teaching homesteaders how to thrive without unnecessary risks or handouts.