HGTV’s Rock the Block Season 6 wrapped up with yet another explosive finale—but this time, the drama didn’t stop when the cameras did. While the network crowned Alison Victoria and Michel Smith Boyd as the official winners, the reaction from fans was anything but celebratory. From accusations of the show being rigged to heated debates about design choices, this season’s results sparked a wildfire of controversy—and now, thanks to a fan-run poll, we finally know who the audience truly believed deserved the win.
A Season Full of Star Power and Tension
Set in Grantsville, Utah, Rock the Block Season 6 featured four powerhouse teams:
-
Alison Victoria & Michel Smith Boyd (Refined Rustic)
-
Chelsea & Cole DeBoer (Cowboy Contemporary)
-
Tristyn & Kamohai Kalama (Moody Modern)
-
Jonathan & Jordan Knight (Modern Farmhouse)
Each team was given a base house valued at $750,000, a renovation budget of $250,000, and an extra $50,000 in bonus money earned during challenges. Their goal? Transform their homes to maximize appraised value and win the title.
But when Victoria and Boyd were declared the winners, fans were quick to express shock, disappointment, and outright suspicion.
Fans Call Foul: “It’s Rigged!”
Almost immediately after the finale aired, social media platforms lit up with heated discussions. Many viewers felt that Tristyn and Kamohai Kalama had delivered the most thoughtful and innovative design—emphasizing functionality, sustainability, and emotional depth. Others favored the DeBoers, who blended modern aesthetics with family-friendly practicality.
On Reddit and Facebook, viewers accused HGTV of favoring Alison Victoria due to her upcoming HGTV series, Sin City Rehab. One commenter bluntly stated, “No coincidence she won—she has a new show to promote.” Others pointed out that her design choices, like the container in the backyard and the indoor pickleball court, felt impractical and gimmicky.
But the backlash didn’t stop there.
Alison’s Fallout Controversy May Have Played a Role
Even before the winner was announced, Alison Victoria found herself at the center of another firestorm—a rumored fallout with teammate Michel Smith Boyd. Fans noticed the two barely interacted during the final episodes. On Instagram, Michel’s cryptic responses and lack of any celebratory post about Alison only fueled the rumors. Some viewers even suggested that Alison’s cold attitude and alleged ego-driven behavior may have influenced public perception of her work.
As one Reddit user wrote:
“Her energy was off all season. She sidelined Michel and made it all about herself. I couldn’t root for that.”
Fans Launch Their Own Poll — and the Results Are Telling
Tired of what they believed was a manipulated outcome, fans took matters into their own hands and launched a poll to determine the true Season 6 winner. Thousands voted, and the results painted a very different picture than HGTV’s.
-
🥇 1st Place: Tristyn & Kamohai Kalama – 33% of votes
Fans applauded their “Moody Modern” design as innovative, heartfelt, and beautifully executed. Their attention to detail and use of solar energy were standout features that resonated with viewers who value smart, sustainable design. -
🥈 2nd Place: Chelsea & Cole DeBoer – 27% of votes
The DeBoers’ “Cowboy Contemporary” home was hailed as the most family-friendly and functional. Their blend of rustic charm and modern flair made their house feel livable and market-ready. -
🥉 3rd Place: Alison Victoria & Michel Smith Boyd – 22% of votes
Despite winning the show, the fanbase was far less convinced. Their design was described by many as “flashy but impractical,” and the lack of chemistry between the teammates didn’t help their public image. -
🏅 4th Place: Jonathan & Jordan Knight – 18% of votes
While many fans found their Modern Farmhouse charming and visually appealing, it lacked the innovation and standout features seen in the other homes
0 Comments